BenchPath

FloridaCircuit 13

Thirteenth Judicial Circuit

Verified judges, local rules, standing orders, and controlling division-assignment orders for Hillsborough County — every entry cites its official source with a last-verified date.

Official site: https://www.fljud13.org

Counties in this circuit

Bench (69 judicial officers)

Circuit judges

Christopher C. Sabella · HillsboroughAlissa Ellison · HillsboroughBarbara Twine Thomas · HillsboroughCaroline Tesche Arkin · HillsboroughCatherine M. Catlin · HillsboroughCheryl Thomas · HillsboroughChristine A. Marlewski · HillsboroughChristopher C. Nash · HillsboroughCory L. Chandler · HillsboroughCynthia Oster · HillsboroughDarren D. Farfante · HillsboroughDaryl M. Manning · HillsboroughDenise A. Pomponio · HillsboroughElizabeth G. Rice · HillsboroughEmily Peacock · HillsboroughFrances M. Perrone · HillsboroughG. Gregory Green · HillsboroughHelene L. Daniel · HillsboroughJ. Logan Murphy · HillsboroughJames S. Moody III · HillsboroughJeffrey M. Rich · HillsboroughJennifer P. Johnson · HillsboroughJennifer X. Gabbard · HillsboroughJessica G. Costello · HillsboroughJoseph M. Tompkins · HillsboroughKatherine G. Essrig · HillsboroughKelly A. Ayers · HillsboroughKim Brennan · HillsboroughKimberly K. Fernandez · HillsboroughLaura E. Ward · HillsboroughLawrence M. Lefler · HillsboroughLeslie K. Schultz-Kin · HillsboroughLindsay M. Alvarez · HillsboroughLisa D. Campbell · HillsboroughLyann Goudie · HillsboroughMark D. Kiser · HillsboroughMark R. Wolfe · HillsboroughMary Lou Cuellar-Stilo · HillsboroughMatthew L. Felix · HillsboroughMelissa C. Black · HillsboroughMelissa M. Polo · HillsboroughMichael J. Hooi · HillsboroughMichael J. Scionti · HillsboroughMichael S. Williams · HillsboroughMichelle D. Sisco · HillsboroughNick Nazaretian · HillsboroughPaul L. Huey · HillsboroughRichard H. Martin · HillsboroughRobert A. Bauman · HillsboroughRobin F. Fuson · HillsboroughThomas N. Palermo · HillsboroughWendy J. DePaul · HillsboroughWesley D. Tibbals · Hillsborough

Titles shown as circuit judges, county judges, and quasi-judicial officers per the official directory.

Recently verified rules

Search all rules →
Courtesy CopiesHillsborough County · County Civil Division J · Judge Michael C. Baggé-Hernández

Digital Courtesy Copies Only; Small Claims & Eviction Procedures Published — County Civil J

Judge Baggé-Hernández runs the fullest county-civil template (13 sections) including dedicated Small Claims and Landlord/Tenant-Eviction procedures — courtesy copies go digitally to the division, JAWS is the scheduling default, and unsolicited non-party communications are disregarded.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Baggé-Hernández Procedures & Preferences (County Civ. J)
Remote / Zoom HearingsHillsborough County · County Civil Division N · Judge Branden M. Henderson

UMC Dockets ARE VIA ZOOM; Other Remote Needs Good Cause — County Civil N

Judge Henderson's practices PDF (mod. May 2026): UMC dockets run on Zoom, other remote appearances require good cause from the requesting party, and unclaimed binders are recycled after 3 days.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Henderson Judicial Practices & Procedures (mod. May 2026) — PDF
Case ManagementHillsborough County · County Criminal Division E · Judge Monique M. Scott

Speedy-Trial Waivers Are Never Accepted by E-Mail — County Criminal E

Judge Scott: all cases in person unless special-set on Zoom (good cause, documentation possible), waivers of speedy trial refused via e-mail — written and filed, or on the record — and every e-mail to the Court copies the opposing party.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Scott Procedures & Standing Orders (County Crim. E)
Remote / Zoom HearingsHillsborough County · County Civil Division I · Judge Christine D. Edwards

UMC Runs on Zoom Only; Cancelled Hearings Kill the Zoom Credentials — County Civil I

Judge Edwards's practices PDF: the Uniform Motion Calendar is conducted via Zoom only, remote-appearance credentials die with a cancelled hearing, and Zoom appearances for in-person settings require an uploaded Order to Appear Via Zoom in the Division I queue.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Edwards Judicial Practices & Procedures (County Civ. I, est. Oct. 20, 2025) — PDF
Courtesy CopiesHillsborough County · County Civil Division L · Judge Christopher Saba

Late Materials Not Considered; Unclaimed Binders Recycled in 3 Days — County Civil L

Judge Saba's practices PDF (mod. Jan. 2026): hearing materials received after the deadline will not be considered, binders not retrieved within 3 days of the proceeding are recycled, and Zoom requests for in-person-noticed hearings go by motion.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Saba Judicial Practices & Procedures (mod. Jan. 2026) — PDF
E-FilingHillsborough County · County Civil Division M · Judge Adam L. Bantner

Bantner Removed His Prior AI Requirements — the Statewide Rule Controls — County Civil M

The strongest in-the-wild confirmation of the 2026 statewide AI rule: Judge Bantner's page expressly states his prior AI requirements are REMOVED because of the May 28, 2026 amendment of Rule 2.515 — signing a filing now itself certifies the authorities exist and are accurately cited.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Bantner Procedures & Preferences (County Civ. M), § 9
Deadlines & Time ComputationHillsborough County · County Criminal Division B · Judge Margaret R. Taylor

In-Custody Continuances 48 Hours Ahead — or the Jail Transport Rolls — County Criminal B

Judge Taylor (under the shared County Criminal Standing Pretrial Order): continuance motions for in-custody defendants must be filed at least 48 hours before the court date to cancel jail transport, and all pleas are in person absent a pre-approved plea in absentia.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Taylor Standing Pretrial Order & Procedures (County Crim. B)
Case ManagementHillsborough County · County Criminal Division D · Judge Christopher Brown

A Notice of Appearance Without a Speedy Waiver Means In-Person Arraignment — County Criminal D

Judge Brown (14-item FSC template, the county-criminal exemplar): in-person default under his Standing Order on Remote Appearances; filing an NOA without waiving speedy trial obligates defendant AND counsel to appear at arraignment; his AI paragraph points to statewide Rule 2.515(d) (compliant).

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Brown Judicial Practices & Procedures (County Crim. D)
Deadlines & Time ComputationHillsborough County · County Criminal Division A · Judge Matthew A. Smith

All Cases In Person; Discovery Motions Within 10 Days of the Due Date — County Criminal A

Judge Smith's practices PDF (mod. Jan. 14, 2026): ALL CASES ARE IN PERSON, discovery-related motions are filed within 10 days after discovery was due, and out-of-custody pleas include a scanned fingerprint card in the filing.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Smith Judicial Practices & Procedures (County Crim. A, mod. Jan. 14, 2026) — PDF
Motion CalendarHillsborough County · County Civil Division H · Judge James S. Giardina

Unilateral Notices Need a Detailed Cover Letter and 3 Documented Attempts — County Civil H

Judge Giardina: 15-minutes-or-less schedules through JAWS, over 30 through the JA — and a unilaterally-set notice of hearing must attach a cover letter detailing at least three attempts to coordinate; hearings in person since February 14, 2022.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Giardina Procedures & Preferences (County Civ. H)
Deadlines & Time ComputationHillsborough County · County Civil Division P · Judge Marc S. Makholm

Mandatory In-Person Appearance; Idle Motions Deemed Abandoned — County Civil P

Judge Makholm's practices PDF (mod. July 1, 2026 — days old): appearance in person is mandatory for the listed settings, and unprosecuted motions "may be deemed abandon[ed]."

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Makholm Judicial Practices & Procedures (mod. July 1, 2026) — PDF
Case ManagementHillsborough County · County Civil Division O · Judge Lisa A. Allen

The Movant Appears Even If the Motion Settled — County Civil O

Judge Allen: every hearing is in person (no phone/Zoom for small-claims initial pretrials), 60-minutes-or-less books through JAWS — and even after the parties agree, the movant must appear at the scheduled time unless a timely cancellation or signed stipulation reached the division.

High confidence· verified July 5, 202613th Jud. Cir., Judge Allen Procedures & Preferences (County Civ. O)