4th Cir. Document — Guidelines Regarding Compulsory Medical Examination
A published requirement of Fourth Judicial Circuit Court (Fourth Judicial Circuit, Florida). Category: Judge Preferences. Cited as 4th Jud. Cir., Guidelines Regarding Compulsory Medical Examination — sha256-hashed 2026-07-25. Verified against the official source (CC-P Civil & Criminal Procedures (Judge Brady) — PDF) on September 9, 2026.
Summary
37 verbatim requirements from Guidelines Regarding Compulsory Medical Examination.
Applies to
Fourth Judicial Circuit (Duval, Clay, Nassau). Procedural information only; not legal advice.
Requirement
• The examination must not be referred to during the actual examination or in front of the jury as an “independent medical exam” or “court ordered medical exam.” • Requests for an examination must set forth the time, place, manner, conditions, and scope of the examination as well as the name of and the qualifications of the person conducting the examination with specificity. • If examinations under these rules are requested such written request should be made no later than 150 days before the pretrial date to allow time for objections, hearings on same and an opportunity to reset the examination. • P. 1.360(a)(1)(A) must be filed no later than 30 days from the written request assuming service of process has occurred at least 15 days prior to the request being served. • The objections must state the specific reasons for the objections. • A hearing must be immediately requested on any objection filed. • P. 1.360(a)(1)(B) [non-physical condition] must be obtained with an order from this Court, or with a written agreement of all parties in the form of an agreed order submitted to this Court. • The date and time of the examination must be coordinated with opposing counsel. • If the attorneys cannot agree on a mutually convenient date for the examination to occur within 45 days of the request, the Court, upon written motion, will pick the date without consultation with counsels’ calendars. • P., governing physical examinations, do not restrict where the examination is to be performed, except that it be set at a “reasonable place.”3 See, also • District Court of Appeal was the first court DCA to address and decide: “whether a nonresident plaintiff must submit to an independent medical examination in Florida.” Tsutras v. • To say that Tsutraes must give up a right (the same right as any other nonresident in so far as the location of an IME is concerned) because they moved from Florida after the accident is, in effect, imposing a continuing Florida residence on the • Davis, 993 So. 2d 99 (Fla. 5th DCA 2008) [clarifying Tsutras to say that the examination must be at a “reasonable place,” not that it required Plaintiff to return to forum especially after he had already come to Florida for a deposition]; • No other attendees shall be present during the examination without specific order of the Court. • Absent a court order stating otherwise, the Defendant and/or Defense Medical Examiner shall not interfere with the Plaintiff’s right to have the above listed persons in attendance and record the • Plaintiff’s counsel will notify, in writing within 10 days of the examination, the names, relationship to the plaintiff, and number of persons who will be present so that an examining room of sufficient size can be reserved. • Neither Plaintiff’s counsel, nor anyone else permitted to be present, shall interject themselves into the examination unless the examiner seeks information not permitted by this • If the person to be examined is not fluent in English and if the examiner is not fluent in the language of the person being examined a certified interpreter must be utilized to interpret the examination. • The medical examiner shall not be entitled to any payment of an additional or accommodation fee from the Plaintiff or his counsel, simply because of the presence • The Court shall reserve ruling as to whether such costs, if imposed by an examiner, may be properly recoverable by the Defendant as a taxable cost, or otherwise awarded by the court. • Co., 566 So. 2d 529 (Fla. 1st DCA 1990) (requesting party must obtain records through normal discovery process). • If a patient information sheet was forwarded to counsel for the party to be examined at least 10 business days before the examination, the party to be examined should bring the completed information sheet with them. 5 If the original records, films or other diagnostic aids are in the actual possession of the party, or his/her guardian, being examined, those records would have to be produced at the time of the examination upon proper written request. • Written intake forms or histories that are deemed necessary by the examiner must be provided to counsel for the party to be examined no later than 10 days prior to the exam. • These forms can be reviewed by counsel and completed by the party to be examined and must be brought to the office of the examiner on the day of the exam. • Defendant’s examiner, the Court shall rule on the need for any such tests prior to the tests being performed. • Further, if such diagnostic tests are ruled necessary by the Court, such tests shall be limited solely to the part(s) of the body at issue in this case. • The party being examined should arrive no later than 15 minutes before the start time of the examination. • Examinations which have been scheduled for a specific time should commence within 30 minutes of that time. • Retained experts must be produced for discovery deposition without the necessity of a subpoena. • If specific items are to be brought to the deposition by the retained expert witness, opposing counsel must be notified well in advance of the deposition. • P. 1.360(b) a “detailed written report” will be issued by the examining physician or healthcare provider and provided to all counsel no later than 30 days after the day of the examination. • The party requesting the examination shall also provide to opposing counsel, at the time the examination is scheduled, no less than three dates when the examiner will be available for oral deposition. • The witness shall be available to be deposed within ten (10) days of rendering the report. • Should any of the dates be within 30 days of the examination, the above referred to CME written report shall be provided to deposing counsel no later than 5 days before the deposition date. • Any changes of opinions or conclusions based on new information must be made known to opposing counsel immediately, a revised or supplemental report provided and dates for updated depositions must also be provided. • All protected health information generated or obtained by the examiner shall be kept in accordance with HIPAA requirements and shall not be disseminated by the examiner or defense counsel to any person or entity not a party to this case without a specific order from this Court. • However, the Court does require full payment to be remitted to the examiner no later than 10 business days from receipt of the invoice from the examiner’s office.
Source of truth
The examination must not be referred to during the actual examination or in front of the jury as an “independent medical exam” or “court ordered medical exam.”
- Official source
- CC-P Civil & Criminal Procedures (Judge Brady) — PDF
- Source health
- Healthy · checked November 15, 2026
- Effective date
- —
- Last verified
- September 9, 2026benchpath-reverify-2026-09-08 (custody hash match) | prior: benchpath-full4-2026-07-25
Reviewer note: Document sha256: 69f3ffa61b8ede6705c757d1241931715712c74c0d658e9458ebd2679266ec4c. Extracted from the document's own text layer. Text layer cleaned 2026-09-08 (Phase 3a): page markers removed; wording untouched. Verbatim from https://www.jud4.org/getContentAsset/7b300110-572c-4258-9bc2-a87b7b8bf1b6/135b97c9-84fa-4e82-b956-0fbccec4aa1f/Division-CV-E-Guidelines-Regarding-Compulsory-Medical-Examinations.pdf?language=en, harvested 2026-07-25; whitespace normalised only. [moved from the text 2026-09-14]
Change history
- July 16, 2026Monitor: CC-P Civil & Criminal Procedures (Judge Brady) — PDF unreachable (timeout or network error).
- July 14, 2026Monitor: CC-P Civil & Criminal Procedures (Judge Brady) — PDF unreachable (timeout or network error).
Related rules
Judge Eric N. Vitaliano (E.D.N.Y.) — Practices and Rules: VI. PROCEDURE FOLLOWING NON-JURY TRIAL
Practices and Rules of Judge Eric N. Vitaliano, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, as the judge's own court page links it: section VI. PROCEDURE FOLLOWING NON-JURY TRIAL — verbatim from the judge's own document (official PDF, sha-custodied). Judge-specific requirement: applies in cases before this judge alongside the Local Rules and the federal rules.
Judge Eric R. Komitee (E.D.N.Y.) — Practices and Rules (CV): I. COMMUNICATIONS
Practices and Rules (CV) of Judge Eric R. Komitee, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, as the judge's own court page links it: section I. COMMUNICATIONS — verbatim from the judge's own document (official PDF, sha-custodied). Judge-specific requirement: applies in cases before this judge alongside the Local Rules and the federal rules.
Seventeenth Cir. — Judge Corey B. Friedman: Judge preferences
1 verbatim requirement on judge preferences.
Judge Eric R. Komitee (E.D.N.Y.) — Practices and Rules (CV): II. ELECTRONIC CASE FILING (ECF)
Practices and Rules (CV) of Judge Eric R. Komitee, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, as the judge's own court page links it: section II. ELECTRONIC CASE FILING (ECF) — verbatim from the judge's own document (official PDF, sha-custodied). Judge-specific requirement: applies in cases before this judge alongside the Local Rules and the federal rules.