Universal Search
Filter by county, category, case type, and confidence. Every result carries its source citation and last-verified date.
Your first 7 Judge Intelligence Reports are free with a free account — no payment card required.
Create your free account →Need the statute or rule itself? Open the Florida Law Library →
● marks a launch county — the deepest coverage tier, where judge, division, and rule ingestion land first.
2 rules
The protocol implementing Welfare & Institutions Code § 709 for the Juvenile Division when a doubt arises as to a minor's competency in a delinquency case, supplementing California Rule of Court 5.645 and Local Rule 622 (if a conflict arises, the law controls): where substantial evidence exists that a minor may be incompetent the court may consider informal resolution (dismissal under Welf. & Inst. Code § 782, evaluation under § 705 and Penal Code § 4011.6, services, and progress review hearings with the consent of the parties); counsel for the minor or the court may express a doubt, proceedings shall be suspended on substantial evidence raising a doubt, and unless the parties stipulate or submit on the minor's lack of competency the court shall appoint an expert; an expert the prosecuting attorney or the minor retains is at that party's cost and disclosed at least five (5) court days prior to the hearing, and a District Attorney expert needs a juvenile court order to evaluate the minor; the appointed expert follows the Checklist for Juvenile Competency Evaluations in the minor's preferred language or with a certified interpreter, has at least fifteen (15) court days to complete the evaluation, and reports in writing to the court at least two (2) court days before the hearing and to minor's counsel, the probation department, and the prosecution; on receipt the parties may stipulate, submit or contest, and a minor the expert opines is developmentally disabled is referred by probation to the Central Valley Regional Center; the competency hearing is set within fifteen (15) court days of receipt for a minor in custody (good cause may extend it briefly) and within forty-five (45) days out of custody; the minor is presumed competent and the party asserting incompetency bears the burden, a minor under the age of 14 first receiving a capacity determination under Penal Code § 26; the minor's statements to an evaluator may not be used in the petitioner's case-in-chief, and the court states an express finding on the record; a competent minor's proceedings are reinstated, a petition with only misdemeanor offenses is dismissed, and on a felony petition all offenses remain suspended while the minor is referred to services in the least restrictive environment consistent with public safety, a probation officer initiating them through Central Valley Regional Center or Kings County Behavioral Health Services (a regional center evaluation within 120 days for a minor not yet its patient); remediation services are reviewed at least every thirty (30) days in custody and every forty-five (45) days out of custody, the § 709(h)(5) factors weighed whenever confinement over six months is considered, and within six months of the initial finding of incompetency an evidentiary hearing leads to reinstatement, return to the program (the total remediation period not to exceed one year) or dismissal of the petition, with persons and agencies invited to the dismissal hearing.
The order (Misc. No. 2026 - 18; dated May 1, 2026 and, as to cases in which Judge Kathy Ciuffini is disqualified, May 4, 2026; filed May 4, 2026): cases wherein judges are recused or disqualified re-assigned pursuant to the order unless otherwise ordered by the court - a table by judge disqualified or recused, type of case, and where the case goes. Judge Jennifer L. Giuliani [Department 1], civil limited, civil unlimited and civil minors compromise cases, to Judge Robert S. Burns [Department 2], then by rotation [D6], [D10], [D5], and Judge Burns's to Judge Giuliani, then by rotation [D6], [D10], [D5]; Commissioner Mark Skinner [Department 3], family support, restraining orders and traffic, to Judge Kendra D. Weber [Department 4], then by rotation [D5], [D10], and Judge Weber's family law cases to Commissioner Skinner, then by rotation [D5], [D10]; Judge Ismael E. Rodriguez [Department 5], criminal misdemeanors, felony and writ petitions, to Judge Marianne C. Gilbert [Department 6], then by rotation [D9], [D7], [D10]; Judge Gilbert, probate, guardianships, conservatorships, probate minor’s compromise, civil UD, commercial residential and residential foreclosure, and prison cases - civil to Judge Rodriguez, then by rotation [D1], [D2], and prison to Judge Rodriguez, then by rotation [D7], [D8], [D10]; Judge Melissa R. D’Morias [Department 7], criminal felony, Care Court and writ petitions, to Judge Kathy Ciuffini [Department 8], then by rotation [D5], [D10], and Judge Ciuffini's criminal felony and writ petitions to Judge D’Morias, then by rotation [D5], [D10]; Judge Risé A. Donlon [Department 9], juvenile delinquency, juvenile dependency and adoptions - delinquency to Judge Jim A. Trevino [D10], then Judge D’Morias [D7], and dependency to Judge Trevino [D10], then Giuliani [D1]; Judge Trevino [Department 10], criminal felony, conflict 602s and 300s, Collaborative Treatment Justice Court and writ petitions, to Judge Donlon [Department 9], then by rotation [D5], [D7]; and a situation not specifically covered by the order determined at the discretion of the Presiding Judge.