Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District — Division Two Miscellaneous Order 22-05: Criminal and Juvenile Trial Counsel Not to Represent Clients on Appeal
A published requirement of Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District (Fourth Appellate District, California). Category: Administrative Orders. Cited as Miscellaneous Order 22-05, Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division Two (Presiding Justice Ramirez), filed February 4, 2022; the court's Miscellaneous Orders book https://appellate.courts.ca.gov/sites/default/files/appellate/default/2023-09/4dca-div2-miscellaneous-orders.pdf, linked from its Local Rules & Orders page https://appellate.courts.ca.gov/district-courts/4dca/rules-forms-filing/local-rules-orders through https://appellate.courts.ca.gov/district-courts/4dca/publication/miscellaneous-orders-4th-district-division-2, read 2026-10-20. Effective February 4, 2022. Verified against the official source (Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District — Local Rules & Orders) on October 20, 2026.
Summary
In criminal and juvenile appeals the court does not appoint the appellant's trial attorney as appellate counsel (People v. Bailey (1992) 9 Cal.App.4th 1252; People v. Kipp (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1100, 1139) and discourages retained or appointed trial counsel, and a public defender's office that represented the client at trial, from representing the appellant beyond filing the notice of appeal; trial counsel may discuss an issue with appointed appellate counsel.
Applies to
California > Fourth Appellate District > Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District
Requirement
MISCELLANEOUS ORDER 22-5 CRIMINAL AND JUVENILE TRIAL COUNSEL NOT TO REPRESENT CLIENTS ON APPEAL THE COURT: In criminal and juvenile appeals, the court will not appoint the appellant’s trial attorney to represent the appellant on appeal, because trial counsel is not able to objectively review the record to determine if trial counsel committed ineffective assistance of counsel. (People v. Bailey (1992) 9 Cal.App.4th 1252, 1254-1255 [trial counsel may not be appointed to represent on appeal the defendant he represented at trial]. See People v. Kipp (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1100, 1139 [“representation by the same attorney at trial and on appeal” entails “‘an inherent conflict’ because counsel ‘is in the untenable position of urging his own incompetency’” citing Bailey with approval].) If trial counsel wants the appeal to raise a particular issue, trial counsel may discuss the issue with appointed appellate counsel. Furthermore and for the same reason, in criminal and juvenile appeals, the court discourages the appellant’s trial attorney, whether retained or appointed by the trial court, from representing appellant on appeal beyond filing the notice of appeal. By “retained” the court refers to all counsel who are not appointed by a court, including without limitation those who have been paid a retainer or fees, those who have received a promise to pay a retainer or fees, and those who have performed or intend to perform appellate attorney services for no compensation. Furthermore and for the same reason, this court discourages the public defender’s office from representing a client the public defender’s office represented at trial in an appeal in which the client is the appellant. Even though Government Code section 27706, subdivision (a), authorizes the public defender to represent on appeal clients the public defender represented at trial, that authorization does not remove the inherent conflict of interest. If the public defender’s office nevertheless decides to represent on appeal a defendant the public defender’s office represented in the trial court, this court urges the public defender’s office to use counsel other than the counsel who represented the appellant in the trial court. The order remains effective unless and until the order is vacated or superseded by an order of this court. RAMIREZ Presiding Justice
Source of truth
MISCELLANEOUS ORDER 22-5 CRIMINAL AND JUVENILE TRIAL COUNSEL NOT TO REPRESENT CLIENTS ON APPEAL THE COURT: In criminal and juvenile appeals, the court will not appoint the appellant’s trial attorney to represent the appellant on appeal, because trial counsel is not able to objectively review the record to determine if trial counsel committed ineffective assistance of counsel. (People v. Bailey (19
- Source health
- Healthy · checked November 15, 2026
- Effective date
- February 4, 2022
- Last verified
- October 20, 2026benchpath-ca-coa-4-2026-10-20
Reviewer note: Composed 2026-10-20 (California Fourth Appellate District build 2026-10-20) from BenchPath custody ca/appellate/ca-coa-4/documents/4dca-div2-miscellaneous-orders.pdf (fetched 2026-10-20; 440969 bytes, sha256 84a13af5f1eb9c60e7deefedaf54981f6a2606e09f1fefed5742557c443105dc): the book's text layer (PyMuPDF text blocks, pages 4 to 38; paragraphs rebuilt from the layout; the running head, the e-filing stamps and the page numbers dropped; the cover and table of orders on pages 1 to 3 are not part of any order). The court's Local Rules & Orders page links the book under “Division 2 – Riverside” as “Miscellaneous Orders for 4th District Division 2”. effective_date: the court's e-filing stamp on the order's first page (“ELECTRONICALLY FILED … Feb 04, 2022”); the order “remains effective unless and until … vacated or superseded”.
Change history
- November 15, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 14, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 13, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 12, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 11, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 10, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 9, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 8, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 7, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
- November 6, 2026Monitor detected a source-content or hash-basis change. Review the archived bytes before republishing dependent material.
Related rules
4th Cir. — AO 1997-10 Amended Administrative Order No. 97-10 Pro Se Referals to Family Mediation
9 verbatim requirements from 4th Circuit Administrative Order 1997-10.
4th Cir. — AO 1997-13 Second Amended Administrative Order No. 97-13 Violation of Open Container Ordinances
6 verbatim requirements from 4th Circuit Administrative Order 1997-13.
4th Cir. — AO 1997-16 Amended Administrative Order No. 97-16 Family Law; Fourth Judicial Circuit Visitation Guid
15 verbatim requirements from 4th Circuit Administrative Order 1997-16.
4th Cir. — AO 1997-18 Administrative Order No. 97-18 Animal Care and Control
5 verbatim requirements from 4th Circuit Administrative Order 1997-18.