Skip to main content

Supreme Court of California — Administrative Order 2023-05-11: Fifth Standing Order Concerning Oral Argument

High confidence· verified October 20, 2026Administrative OrdersAdministrative Order 2023-05-11 (Fifth Standing Order Concerning Oral Argument), Supreme Court of California, en banc, filed May 11, 2023; the court's file https://supreme.courts.ca.gov/sites/default/files/supremecourt/default/2023-05/admin.%20order%202023-05-11.pdf, linked from https://supreme.courts.ca.gov/news-and-events/administrative-order-2023-05-11, read 2026-10-20.

A published requirement of Supreme Court of California (California). Category: Administrative Orders. Cited as Administrative Order 2023-05-11 (Fifth Standing Order Concerning Oral Argument), Supreme Court of California, en banc, filed May 11, 2023; the court's file https://supreme.courts.ca.gov/sites/default/files/supremecourt/default/2023-05/admin.%20order%202023-05-11.pdf, linked from https://supreme.courts.ca.gov/news-and-events/administrative-order-2023-05-11, read 2026-10-20. Effective May 11, 2023. Verified against the official source (Supreme Court of California — E-Filing & Procedures) on October 20, 2026.

Summary

The court's standing protocols for in-person oral argument (in San Francisco since November 2022 and, from June 2023, in some sessions elsewhere), counsel keeping the option to appear in person or remotely by video: the courtroom is open to the public and media, seating first come, first served absent arrangements through the Clerk / Executive Officer; no one enters who has tested positive for COVID-19 within five days, awaits a test result, has had a fever within 24 hours or has had symptoms for five days; masking follows any state or local directive in effect; every counsel who will appear files the appearance form within seven calendar days after the case is set for argument, electing remote appearance on the form and notifying opposing counsel (no preference stated means in person; the clerk's office and technical staff test remote connections in advance); counsel who become unable to appear in person for extraordinary medical cause notify opposing counsel and the clerk at once to arrange remote participation, subject to the court's discretion; attendees who develop symptoms or test positive within five days after the session notify the clerk's office; argument is live-streamed and archived. Supersedes Administrative Orders 2020-03-13, 2020-03-27, 2020-08-19 and 2022-10-05. Signed by the Chief Justice and the six Associate Justices.

Applies to

California > Supreme Court of California

Requirement

ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER 2023-05-11 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF CALIFORNIA EN BANC FIFTH STANDING ORDER CONCERNING ORAL ARGUMENT In November 2022, the court resumed in-person oral argument in its San Francisco courtroom. Beginning in June 2023, the court will resume its practice of conducting some in-person oral argument sessions in locations other than San Francisco. As with oral argument conducted in San Francisco, counsel will have the option to appear in person at these sessions, or remotely via video. Henceforth, and subject to further order of the court, the following protocols will apply at all in-person oral arguments: 1. The courtroom where oral argument will occur will be open to the public and media. Absent prior arrangements made through the court's Clerk / Executive Officer, seating will be on a first come, first served basis. Seating may be limited in order to achieve appropriate social distancing. 2. No person shall enter the courtroom if that person (a) has tested positive for COVID-19 within the previous five days; (b) is ill and currently awaiting the results of a COVID-19 test; (c) has had a fever within the prior 24 hours; or (d) has had symptoms consistent with COVID-19 that have persisted over the previous five days. 3. The court will enforce any masking requirements as may be imposed by relevant state or local health directives in effect at the time of the oral argument session. 4. All counsel who will appear must file a form within seven calendar days after the case is set for argument (click here for appearance form). Counsel who elect to appear remotely via video must so indicate on the form, and simultaneously notify opposing counsel. Counsel who do not indicate a preference on the form will be expected to appear in person. All counsel who will appear remotely will be contacted by the court's clerk's office and technical staff for instruction and to test connections in advance of argument. Counsel may appear in person even if other counsel in a case elect to appear remotely. 5. Any counsel who initially planned to appear in person for oral argument but who becomes unable to do so for extraordinary cause related to medical reasons (including a positive COVID-19 test in advance of oral argument) must notify opposing counsel and the clerk of the court immediately regarding, and to arrange for, remote participation via video. The court retains discretion to deny the request, grant it and allow for remote participation, postpone oral argument if necessary, or take other action as may be appropriate. 6. All individuals, including counsel and members of the public, who attend in-person oral argument shall notify the clerk's office at sc.oralargument.forms@jud.ca.gov upon exhibiting symptoms of, or testing positive for, COVID-19 within five days after the in-person session. 7. The public will continue to have access to argument via live streaming on the Judicial Branch website, https://supreme.courts.ca.gov. Recordings of oral arguments will continue to be archived for subsequent viewing. This order supersedes Administrative Orders 2020-03-13 (Mar. 16, 2020), 2020-03-27 (Mar. 27, 2020), 2020-08-19 (Aug. 19, 2020)., and 2022-10-05 (October 5, 2022). GUERRERO, Chief Justice CORRIGAN, J., Associate Justice LIU, J., Associate Justice KRUGER, J., Associate Justice GROBAN, J., Associate Justice JENKINS, J., Associate Justice EVANS, J., Associate Justice

Source of truth

ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER 2023-05-11 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF CALIFORNIA EN BANC FIFTH STANDING ORDER CONCERNING ORAL ARGUMENT In November 2022, the court resumed in-person oral argument in its San Francisco courtroom. Beginning in June 2023, the court will resume its practice of conducting some in-person oral argument sessions in locations other than San Francisco. As with oral argument conducted in Sa
Source health
Healthy · checked November 15, 2026
Effective date
May 11, 2023
Last verified
October 20, 2026benchpath-ca-supreme-2026-10-20

Reviewer note: Composed 2026-10-20 (California Supreme Court build 2026-10-20) from BenchPath custody ca/appellate/ca-supreme/documents/admin.-order-2023-05-11.pdf (fetched 2026-10-20; 88126 bytes, sha256 40d9cdecdc248f5da05c4352430ece879a492f11963003daa54625e8356b832d): a two-page scanned file with no text layer, rendered to page images (renders/) and transcribed by eye; the clerk's filing stamp (“SUPREME COURT FILED MAY 11 2023 Jorge Navarrete Clerk / Deputy”) is not part of the text; the signature block is rendered as each justice's name and title; the order's own “(click here for appearance form)” link text is reproduced. The appearance form it refers to (https://supreme.courts.ca.gov/sites/default/files/supremecourt/default/2022-10/Supreme_Court_Oral_Argument_Appearance_Form_0.pdf, receipted and held for the forms lane) allows each side 30 minutes (45 in a death penalty appeal on written request by the return date), one counsel per side unless the court orders otherwise on request. effective_date = May 11, 2023, the filing date; the order applies “henceforth, and subject to further order of the court”.

Related rules

Administrative OrdersFourth Judicial Circuit

4th Cir. — AO 1997-10 Amended Administrative Order No. 97-10 Pro Se Referals to Family Mediation

9 verbatim requirements from 4th Circuit Administrative Order 1997-10.

High confidence· verified September 8, 2026Fourth Judicial Circuit Administrative Order 1997-10, filed 05/29/1997, published on the Duval Clerk's administrative-orders store — sha256-hashed 2026-08-03
Administrative OrdersFourth Judicial Circuit

4th Cir. — AO 1997-13 Second Amended Administrative Order No. 97-13 Violation of Open Container Ordinances

6 verbatim requirements from 4th Circuit Administrative Order 1997-13.

High confidence· verified August 3, 2026Fourth Judicial Circuit Administrative Order 1997-13, filed 06/27/1997, published on the Duval Clerk's administrative-orders store — sha256-hashed 2026-08-03
Administrative OrdersFourth Judicial Circuit

4th Cir. — AO 1997-16 Amended Administrative Order No. 97-16 Family Law; Fourth Judicial Circuit Visitation Guid

15 verbatim requirements from 4th Circuit Administrative Order 1997-16.

High confidence· verified August 3, 2026Fourth Judicial Circuit Administrative Order 1997-16, filed 01/22/1998, published on the Duval Clerk's administrative-orders store — sha256-hashed 2026-08-03
Administrative OrdersFourth Judicial Circuit

4th Cir. — AO 1997-18 Administrative Order No. 97-18 Animal Care and Control

5 verbatim requirements from 4th Circuit Administrative Order 1997-18.

High confidence· verified August 3, 2026Fourth Judicial Circuit Administrative Order 1997-18, filed 10/04/1997, published on the Duval Clerk's administrative-orders store — sha256-hashed 2026-08-03